Written By Sam Gordon & Madelynne Whitt

Directed By Sam Gordon for the Players Theatre Self-Producing Residency in December 2025

In this innovative, choose your own adventure style production, the audience is tasked with making real choices that have real consequences; After a messy breakup with her long-term, on-again, off-again boyfriend, Daphne turns to God for guidance in the romance department. To her surprise, God answers! The following day, we meet three very different potential love interests who leave Daphne with a huge decision that can only be made with the help of a little divine intervention. As workplace chaos, toxic exes, and family drama unfolds, rest assured Daphne is going to need a lot more help.

Production Team:

Executive Producers - John and Cynthia Tobin, Anna Marie Tobin (AMT)

Co-Producer - Daisy Theatricals

Playwrights - Sam Gordon & Madelynne Whitt

Director - Sam Gordon

Assistant Director - Anna Marie Tobin (AMT)

Stage Manager - Anna Marie Tobin (AMT)

Sound Design - Anna Marie Tobin (AMT)

Lighting Design - Zoe Griffith

Costume Design - Sam Gordon

Marketing Director - Katie Brown

Logo Design - Nicole Huelskamp

Cast

Daphne - Haley Henson

God - Jai Pruitt

Juliet - Kayla Smith

Jenny - Sheena Zhang

Smith - Logan Rhys

Daisy - Alison Hagen

Joshua - Ranier Acosta

Colin Jr. - Jonah Goldman

Colin Sr. - Milton Daniel Lopez

Colleen - Jamie Cayer

Chelsea - Lea Hulsey

Donna - Avery Pate

Swings: Chloe Rigler-Gryj, Campbell Pate, Aaron Lamm, Skylar D’Andrea

The Divine Dating Game

Photos by Maria Urbie-Duarte & Madeline Saintsing